
Moxy Brooklyn Williamsburg
Best for lively nights out, rooftop skyline views and a social Brooklyn neighborhood experience.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Moxy Brooklyn Williamsburg is a 216-room, nightlife-forward boutique on Bedford Avenue with rooftop bars, music-led venues and an all-season garden — good for travelers who want a social, Brooklyn-flavored stay. The Peninsula New York is a classic Fifth Avenue luxury hotel with a full-service spa, indoor pool and formal dining — aimed at travelers who want traditional Manhattan elegance and service.
Updated · about 6.0 km apart

Best for lively nights out, rooftop skyline views and a social Brooklyn neighborhood experience.

Best for classic Fifth Avenue luxury, a full-service spa and an indoor pool with formal service levels.
When Moxy Brooklyn Williamsburg wins: pick Moxy if you want a younger, nightlife-driven stay with rooftop bars, a music lounge and event-ready spaces in Williamsburg — ideal for groups and guests who plan to spend evenings in the neighborhood.
When The Peninsula New York wins: choose The Peninsula for a traditional, service-oriented Manhattan stay near 5th Avenue and MoMA with a full-service spa, indoor pool and formal dining options.
Bottom line: both hotels place you centrally for different New York experiences — Moxy for Brooklyn energy and nightlife, The Peninsula for Fifth Avenue luxury and classic city-center conveniences.
| Category | Moxy Brooklyn Williamsburg | The Peninsula New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Lively, music-forward Brooklyn boutique with rooftop nightlife | Classic Fifth Avenue luxury hotel with formal service |
| Location | Bedford Avenue, Williamsburg, Brooklyn — near Domino Park and music venues | 700 Fifth Avenue at 55th Street — steps from 5th Avenue and MoMA |
| Size (rooms) | 216 rooms | 219 guestrooms |
| Age policy / check-in | Main guest must be at least 21 to check in | |
| Pools | No pool on-site | Indoor pool (1) |
| Restaurants & bars | LilliStar (rooftop), Bar Bedford (café/cocktail bar), Mesiba (Levantine), Jolene Sound Room | Clement Restaurant (American) plus 3 bars/lounges and 24-hour room service |
| Spa & wellness | No on-site full-service spa; 24/7 fitness centre and outdoor pickleball court | Full-service spa, 24-hour health club and sauna |
| Known for | Rooftop views, DJ-driven nightlife, event spaces and pickleball garden | Fifth Avenue address, traditional luxury service and spa/pool |
| Accessibility & transport | Near multiple subway lines and NYC Ferry; no on-site parking or airport shuttle | Centrally located in Midtown Manhattan; valet/secured parking (surcharge) and limo/town car service available |
Moxy sits on Bedford Avenue in the heart of Williamsburg, close to waterfront parks and live-music venues.
Choose Moxy for a neighborhood-forward Brooklyn stay with convenient transit into Manhattan.
The Peninsula is on Fifth Avenue at 55th Street, steps from museums, flagship stores and Midtown attractions.
Choose The Peninsula for immediate access to Midtown Manhattan’s museums, theaters and shopping.
Moxy’s 216 rooms include standard and bunk-bed configurations for flexible group layouts.
Moxy’s rooms are practical, flexible and aimed at social groups and younger travelers.
The Peninsula’s 219 guestrooms are finished to a classic luxury standard with premium bedding.
The Peninsula focuses on traditional luxury-room categories, upgraded bedding and in-room conveniences.
Moxy centers dining and drinking around social, music-led venues and a rooftop bar.
Moxy’s food and drink program is built for social hours, DJs and late-night crowds.
The Peninsula offers formal dining and several bars/lounges typical of a Fifth Avenue luxury hotel.
The Peninsula provides classic, service-led dining and multiple lounge options suited to Midtown guests.
Moxy’s standout on-site amenity is its year-round outdoor pickleball court in the garden and rooftop venues.
Moxy’s signature amenities favor active, social programming rather than a traditional pool or spa.
The Peninsula’s key leisure features include a full-service spa, indoor pool and 24-hour health club.
The Peninsula is a better fit if you prioritize an indoor pool and full spa services during your stay.
Moxy is positioned around nightlife — DJs, late-night lounge hours and rooftop cocktails.
If late-night social life and music are central to your trip, Moxy is the clear fit.
The Peninsula emphasizes traditional wellness: spa treatments, sauna and an indoor pool.
Pick The Peninsula if you prefer quieter, service-driven wellness options over nightlife.

Moxy — rooftop LilliStar, late-night Jolene Sound Room and an on-site DJ-friendly program.

The Peninsula — steps from 5th Avenue, MoMA and Rockefeller Center.

The Peninsula — full-service spa, indoor pool and sauna.

Moxy — flexible event spaces, rooftop and several buyout-capable music/venue rooms.
Moxy Brooklyn Williamsburg — designed around rooftop bars, a music lounge and late-night programming; Jolene Sound Room runs late-night events (21+).
The Peninsula New York — it lists a full-service spa, an indoor pool and a sauna. Moxy does not have an on-site pool and does not publish a full-service spa.
Both list LaGuardia as a preferred/nearby airport; travel times vary with traffic — The Peninsula is in Midtown Manhattan while Moxy is in Williamsburg, Brooklyn.
The Peninsula — walking distance to MoMA, Rockefeller Center and Fifth Avenue shopping; choose Moxy if you want a Brooklyn neighborhood base with easy subway or ferry access into Manhattan.
Explore how Moxy Brooklyn Williamsburg stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·